Boundless Pages

Where Thoughts Flow Freely!

We Need to Talk About Modern Romance Books (Because Honestly, What Is Going On?)

Alright, gather round. We need to talk.
And no, it’s not a coincidence, I’ve been seeing this trend everywhere. Let’s start from the very beginning, shall we?

I read books. All kinds of books. History, romance, fantasy, thriller, self-help, psychology, you name it, it’s on my shelf (or shamefully buried in my “to be read” pile).

Lately, I’ve noticed something very disturbing in modern romance novels: women are being portrayed as absolutely pathetic.
Begging for love. Desperate for male attention. And I, for one, am sick of it.

Back in the day, I used to skip the parts where the girl was sobbing over some emotionally unavailable bloke who barely noticed she existed, and of course, at the end, he’d “choose” her simply because, well, she was the last one standing. Romantic, right? (No. Just no.)

Case Study in Tragic: Flock by Kate Stewart

Let’s get specific:
I recently read Flock by Kate Stewart. The main character, Cecilia, was so pitiful I wanted to reach through the pages, grab her by the shoulders and give her a good shake. Girl, WAKE UP!
She falls for not one, but two men (because one wasn’t enough to ruin her self-esteem, apparently), who treat her like dirt and toss her the barest scraps of affection, and she’s absolutely fine with it.

Reading this book had me so furious I physically threw it across the room a few times… yet somehow, I soldiered on and finished it (because Dustin paid for it lol). By the end, I didn’t know whether I felt more sorry for her or angry that she’d made me waste hours of my life on her tragic love story.

Honestly, maybe the real problem is me. Maybe I expect too much like basic respect, decency, and human kindness in a relationship. Wild, I know (Imagine me rolling my eyes here)

The Bigger Problem: What Are We Teaching Young Women?

Here’s the scary bit:
Younger girls are reading these same books, internalising these toxic narratives and thinking this is what romance should look like.
“Oh, how romantic! He ignored me for months, but in the end, he realised he loved me!”
Meanwhile, I’m over here thinking, “Babe, he couldn’t even text you back.”

Is it any wonder so many stay in toxic relationships? Is it any wonder they believe love equals pain?

Why Can’t We Have Nice Things (Like Healthy Relationships)?

Why don’t more authors write characters with actual backbone?
Men and women who have strong character, proper values, and, I know this is revolutionary “self-respect“.

Why do we glorify kidnapping, assault, emotional damage, and call it “dark romance”?
At this point, if a book is marketed as dark romance, I immediately assume it’s about a bloke treating his girlfriend like rubbish, while she’s so traumatised she thinks it’s “true love”. Hard pass, thanks.

Good Books Do Exist (Thankfully)

There are books out there that get it right.
The Nightingale by Kristin Hannah (no relation, sadly) and the Empyrean series by Rebecca Yarros, absolute gems.
Strong women, actual self-worth, proper story arcs. Not just endless crying into pillows waiting for Mr. Toxic to get his act together.

Conclusion (Before I Throw Another Book Across the Room)

So here’s my public service announcement for the week:
If you know any good books where people are not “miserably in love” with each other, please let me know.
Save me. Save the bookshelves. Save the next generation (i know i am drametic).

Loads of love (and a bit of exasperation),
Hannah

11 responses to “We Need to Talk About Modern Romance Books (Because Honestly, What Is Going On?)”

  1. Thanks

    this is great

    Like

  2. I see where you’re getting at. To be honest, I prefer adventure and action to other genres but the few times I’ve read romance under the suggestions of my friends, I’ve never really regretted it. Sure, I hated watching the Twilight movies and I’m thankful that I never read the books but usually I trusted my friends. And currently, I’m exploring the ‘Powerless’ romantasy trilogy by Lauren Roberts and I love it so far. One thing I really like about it is that the series has a powerful and inspiring female character. So haha, here’s my attempt at saving you from dark romance.

    Hope you find and enjoy more books that doesn’t involve people ‘miserably being in love’ with each other!

    Cheers!

    Phoenix

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Heya Phoenix,

      Thank you so much for your lovely suggestion. I’ve seen Powerless in bookshops quite a few times but wasn’t sure whether to buy it or not, but now that you’ve recommended it, I definitely will. I’ve just bought A Court of Thorns and Roses, so I’ll read that first and then move on to Powerless x

      Sending love all the way from Japan,
      Hannah

      Liked by 1 person

  3. perhaps Jane Austin is good? I know Pride and Prejudice is a classic along with essentially all of her stories.
    I do find the dark romance to be for the fulfillment of a particular fetish perhaps or something else that I don’t understand.
    I love you darling

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you for your lovely suggestions, I will look into it, cheeers!
      Love you back x

      Like

  4. Basic respect, decency, and human kindness? No, no, no. This is MODERN love. Denigration, INdecency and human posSESSiveness, crippling conventional expectation and media escapism, all seasoned with plentiful sprinklings of appeasement, “compromise” and ~ when all else fails, which, darlin’, it’s expected to ~ unresolved issues brushed under the rug with “make-up sex.”

    You can see where you’ve gone way wrong with this. I’ll bet you don’t even LIKE a “good healthy” emotional hysterical totally unproductive ARgument! You’re HOPEless!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Haha, honestly, you paint a painfully accurate (and hilarious) picture of a lot of what’s considered “normal” in modern love. It’s sad how often real connection gets replaced by chaos and performance these days.
      I guess I’m just stubborn (or maybe hopelessly old-fashioned) enough to believe it doesn’t have to be that way. That maybe “just maybe” we deserve love that’s kind, calm, real, and doesn’t need destruction to feel exciting x

      Like

      1. Well, you’ve got company here ~ that’s two of us!

        Liked by 1 person

  5. A much needed criticism! I wonder if sadly, people gravitate to those books because they can see themselves in the stories. So many people don’t realize that they deserve better! We need more books that show us better examples for sure!
    – Whitley

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Couldn’t agree more ❤️❤️

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a comment